Enhanced dividends: is there a catch?
Investment trusts have been popular with income investors for generations, but a growing trend has emerged among some going another route to produce their dividends, ideally with a greater level of consistency and portfolio flexibility.
Several trusts have adopted what's called an ‘enhanced dividend’ policy, which involves committing to paying a dividend based on a fixed percentage of net asset value (NAV), or a predetermined level, say 4%, even if some of that payment has to come from capital gains.
This compares to the more ‘traditional’ method of funding the dividend strictly from the ‘natural’ yield of its underlying holdings. This is how many of the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) Dividend Heroes have operated, a title earned when trusts have increased their dividend every year for at least the past 20 years.
While the longest-running heroes can boast almost 60 years of growing dividends annually, it’s not always guaranteed and as AJ Bell discovered, not all of them have kept pace with inflation with dividend increases. And while the headline of annual dividend growth is extremely attractive, it’s often by very small amounts.
Why do trusts go for an enhanced method?
An enhanced dividend policy can give shareholders greater certainty around the income they can expect, which could be highly attractive for those moving into retirement who rely more on dividends as a source of income in place of a paycheque.
It also allows trusts to invest in more growth-style stocks and targets what they think are the best companies from a total return perspective, without having to exclusively prioritise a certain level of yield from their investments.
This can help improve the overall performance of the trust in the long term, since managers are under less pressure to generate income in the near term, but at the expense of future capital growth.
Take JPMorgan Global Growth and Income, which adopted an enhanced dividend policy back in 2016. Its top 10 holdings include tech giants Nvidia, Microsoft, Amazon and TSMC, none of which offer particularly generous dividend yields. Contrast that to the City of London, which has increased its dividend annually for the past 60 years with the more ‘traditional’ method, and invests in 'classic' income stocks such as HSBC, Shell and BAE Systems and only 1% in tech.
Cannibalising itself in lean years
The enhanced policy works well in years when the trust is on the up, but as with every investment this isn’t a guarantee.
Let’s say trust X has committed to a 4% annual dividend but only receives a 2% yield from its holdings then the value of its investments would need to grow by at least 2% just to stay the same size. If the returns are less, then the assets sold to help fund the dividend would shrink the value of the wider portfolio. If this persists over time the fund could get smaller and smaller, effectively cannibalising itself to meet its dividend payments and leaving less capital with which to generate future returns.
One of the unique functions of investment trusts is that they can hold back a portion of their profits during good years to build a revenue reserve (like a rainy-day cash pile). This is what allowed many of them to continue to maintain and even grow their dividends during the pandemic, when many of their underlying stocks either cut or cancelled their dividends to shore up their balance sheets.
Enhanced income trusts can do this as well, but, if their reserve isn’t as large because they don’t receive as much in dividends from their underlying holdings, then the level of buffer could be smaller.
A trust could potentially become a forced seller of its investments to generate the actual cash it’s promised to payout.
