Five financial traps facing men – and ways to escape them
On average men are in a far stronger financial position than women. Among full-time workers, men make 6.8% more than women on average, they’re more likely to invest in a Stocks and shares ISA and have a bigger pension pot. They’re also less likely to have low savings levels, to be financially vulnerable or face low financial resilience.
But while this puts many men in a strong financial position, they’re not entirely out of the woods, because we all make mistakes. And while there’s nothing specifically male about any kinds of financial mistakes, the pressures on men can make some things more of a risk, so it’s worth being aware of the traps that may lie in store, and the best ways to escape them.
1. Men may feel they should already be money experts
In a 2024 study, men in the UK were asked if they agreed with the phrase ‘expenses are a man’s responsibility, even if his wife can help him’, and fewer than 15% agreed. However, when asked what their community thought, almost 45% said most other people would agree with the statement. It means men can feel the weight of other people’s expectations that they ought to be good with money, which can hold them back from asking questions and seeking help.
In reality, financial education in schools isn’t universally good, so nobody needs to feel any embarrassment about not understanding something they’ve never been taught. It’s worth reading financial articles, listening to specialist podcasts, watching YouTube videos by experts, and talking to the people in your life with more experience of money matters to get a better understanding.
2. Tying risk up with masculinity
A recent LSE (London School of Economics) paper examined a coin toss experiment, where people could choose a safe amount of money or a risky bet. Men who were less confident in their masculinity were more likely to opt for the risky side of the bet – 50.2% of the time compared to 47.9% for other men.
They were also likely to opt for the risky bet even when the potential reward wasn’t much better than the safe bet – something more secure men shied away from. The higher the stakes, the more the insecure men were likely to gamble – and the less likely other men were to. It concluded that some more insecure men may be using risk taking in investment to perform their masculinity, including investing in highly risky assets like crypto currency.
The more people understand about investment, the less it runs the risk of getting mixed up with other psychological drivers, because the easier it is to test whether the risk level is right for your overall portfolio.
3. Building confidence slightly faster than knowledge
Financial confidence is a life-changing attribute, but it’s vital it’s developed in lock step with understanding. The FCA asked men and women to assess their own financial capability – their confidence in managing money, their knowledge about financial matters and whether they consider themselves savvy consumers, and while 20% of women scored themselves as having low financial capability, only 14% of men did.
While some of this can be explained by the fact men tend to answer financial questions correctly slightly more often than women, there’s a risk some of this is over-confidence. Behavioural finance shows that male investors, on average, are likely to trade more than women and take risks that don’t improve their returns, which researchers ascribe to over-confidence.
This shouldn’t mean that confidence takes a knock, just that it’s worth devoting some time to making sure your knowledge keeps pace, so you can see where your investment performance has come from, the impact of trading costs and whether your approach is adding value, or whether it could benefit from a few tweaks.
4. Taking on too many financial commitments
It’s incredibly easy to fall victim to lifestyle creep. Studies have shown that given the opportunity, men tend to choose competitive environments more than women, so there’s a risk that they become competitive when it comes to lifestyle and status symbols too.
The practical solution is to understand how much cash you have available to spend each month, so you don't accidentally overspend. There are plenty of free budgeting apps that can help you keep track. Psychologically it’s worth considering why you are buying these things. More use of social media tends to make people more materialistic, especially when they are looking at the accounts of people showing off their lifestyles. If this is affecting your buying decisions, it’s worth avoiding the accounts and content that trigger the worst envy.
5. Waiting too long to get help
Given the fact we’re all human, and we all make mistakes, there will be times in our life when our finances aren’t pretty. In some cases, we can make all the necessary changes and turn things around on our own, but sometimes we need help. In these circumstances, the sooner we ask for help, the less of a problem we’ll have built, and the easier it is to solve.
The problem is that some men may find it too difficult to ask for help, which may be tied into how so many men feel that society expects them to be good with money, so there’s shame involved when things don’t go to plan. It’s why it’s so important that we recognise the strength it takes to take control, and get the help we need.
